S3 Episode 4: Super Bowl Commercials – Do They Really Work?

Link to episode:

Featured Guests:

Anaka Kobzev
Background: Global communications (McCann, TBWA)
Founder and Principal of Through Line Advisory

Amelea Renshaw
Head of Strategy at Lucky Generals NY

This year, companies spent $8–10 million for a single 30-second Super Bowl commercial, before production, celebrity fees, and amplification even begin. It’s one of the biggest marketing bets any company can make, and one of the few remaining moments of true mass, real-time cultural attention.

In this episode, the panel tackles the real question behind the hype:

Do Super Bowl commercials actually work, or are brands gambling millions on a flashy coin flip?

To answer this question, we’re joined by featured guests and ad agency experts Anaka Kobzev (main episode and included post-show) and Amelea Renshaw (post-show) who have both been instrumental in shaping Super Bowl campaigns, among other things:

• Anaka has led global communications for legendary agencies like McCann and TBWA and is Founder and Principal of Through Line Advisory, helping brands to elevate their visibility through strategic communications and content. 
• Amelea is Head of Strategy at Lucky Generals NY, spearheading brand positioning, award-winning creative campaigns, and comms thinking for brands such as Universal (with a 2026 ad spot), Ally, Google, Peloton, Pinterest, and Girls Who Code.

Recorded in two parts, the episode opens with a pre-game breakdown, where the panel evaluates the economics, risks, and strategic rationale behind Super Bowl advertising. After the game, the conversation continues with a bonus after-show, analyzing what actually aired, which ads cut through, which ones missed, and what patterns emerged across categories like AI, finance, health, food and beverage.

With perspectives from brand strategy, communications leadership, and deep agency experience, the group goes beyond “Was it funny?” and instead evaluates ROI, readiness, cultural fit, and long-term brand impact.

Key Topics & Takeaways

• Why Super Bowl ads now cost 2–3× more than a decade ago
• The difference between awareness, engagement, and actual business impact
• When Super Bowl ads amplify strength vs expose weakness
• Why creative misalignment can erase millions in value
• The danger of confusing celebrity recognition with brand recall
• How layoffs, market timing, and internal morale affect ad perception
• Why some brands win with one ad and others disappear entirely
• The rise of AI, health, and fintech themes in this year’s game
• How pre-game leaks and post-game amplification now matter as much as game night

Strategic Frameworks Discussed

• Readiness Test: If your operations can’t handle the spike, don’t buy the spot
• Lifecycle Fit: Super Bowl ads work best at inflection points, not desperation moments
• Creative Discipline: Entertainment alone is not strategy
• Before / During / After: The ad is the spark, not the fire
• Internal Alignment: Employees must understand the “why,” not just see the spend
• Cultural Context: Tone matters as much as message

Who This Episode Is For

• CMOs and brand leaders
• Marketing and communications executives
• Agency strategists and creatives
• Founders considering big-budget awareness plays
• Anyone curious why some Super Bowl ads become legendary and others become memes
• The Big Question This Episode Answers
• Is a Super Bowl commercial a smart investment or a very expensive ego play?

Final Take

Super Bowl commercials can work, but only when the entire business is ready to support the moment. Without operational strength, creative clarity, and strategic intent, the biggest stage in advertising doesn’t save brands, it exposes them.

The real win isn’t airtime.

It’s alignment, execution, and what happens after the confetti settles.

Episode Participants

• Aaron Wolpoff
• Melissa Eaton
• Chino Nnadi
• Anaka Kobzev (Special Guest)
• Amelea Renshaw (Special Guest, post-game analysis)

Links:
Website – wefixeditpod.com

Follow us on:
Instagram/wefixeditpod
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/wefixeditpod
YouTube/@wefixeditpod

If you liked this episode, don’t forget to subscribe, leave a review, and share it with your friends! Keep listening to find out how we fix companies and put them back better than we found them.